Region D DMERC Advisory Committee
PRESENT
DAC Representatives:
Laura McIlvaine, Chair John Allman Denise Arnold
Reid Bellis Kel Bergman Richard Butler
Collin Cooke Phil Danz Vince DeStigter
Michelle Dudley Mark Ephraim Ed Erickson
Shelagh Foster Kim Frushon Velma Goertzen
Adea Goselin Rick Graver Syd Gubin
Diana Guth Sarah Haines Matt Hake
Maureen Hanna Craig Harris Mike Hayden
Wade Hendrickson Gary Hill David Hosman
Janna Jurovich John Kenney Kelley Kirkpatrick
Herb Langsam Miriam Lieber Connie Lind-Fraher
Joe McKnight W.B. Mick Sharon Nichelson
Traci Ostwalt Julie Paz Troy Paz
Gloria Peterson Marshall Pollock Bill Potrykus
Rich Pozesky Robert Raschke Carlos Reyes
Kimberlie Rogers-Bowers Sheila Showalter Martin Szmal
Val Taylor Mary Turner Paul T. Webber
Rosalie Webber
CIGNA Staff:
Dr. Robert Hoover Dolly Baughman Doug Frazier
Mary Rheinecker
Laura McIlvaine, Chair called the meeting to order and began introductions.
Comments from Dr. Hoover
Dr. Hoover gave the DAC an update on several key issues. He reported that the next edition of
the DMERC Dialogue would contain key changes including modifier changes and 13 policy
revisions.
2
He reported that DynCorp, in its CERT process, has been reviewing the application of policy by
the DMERCs. As a result, providers will begin to see a stricter application of policy (e.g., the use
of RT/LT modifiers on claims).
Dr. Hoover also explained a pilot program that CIGNA will work on with CMS. The project will
allow beneficiaries to shop for their wheelchairs and negotiate pricing. Providers in Region D
will not likely be affected by this pilot project; however, an article will appear in the next
DMERC Dialogue.
Providers will see a change in the focus of the DMERC Dialogue. The new focus will be to
identify key denial reasons and make suggestions on how providers can avoid denials. Dr.
Hoover indicated that CIGNA would begin working closely with the DAC Education A-Team to
address claim errors.
ADMC
Dr. Hoover asked for feedback on the ADMC process. Val Taylor indicated that the status of
prior ADMC issues reviewed by the DAC have been resolved.
Wade Hendrickson asked about provider utilization of ADMC. Dr. Hoover responded that the
number of requests had increased; however, about 20% of the requests received have been
invalid.
C-PAP Policy
Dr. Hoover reviewed the timeline for implementing the new C-PAP Policy.
Dale Cleveland asked Dr. Hoover to define how providers should "ascertain" that a patient is
complying with CPAP therapy as defined in the new policy. Dr. Hoover indicated that providers
could call the beneficiary to see if they are compliant. However, this is probably not the best way
for providers to document compliance. Dr. Hoover recommended that providers obtain written
confirmation of compliance. He indicated that follow-up would have to be documented in the
provider file for post payment audit reasons. The policy leaves how that documentation is
obtained up to the provider.
Dale Cleveland asked Dr. Hoover for clarification on what an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ)
can review in the way of overriding policy. Dr. Hoover indicated that an ALJ can only review a
Local Medical Review Policy (LMRP) and has no authority to review a National Coverage
Decision (NCD).
The DAC inquired about using polysomnograms dated prior to April 1st to qualify beneficiaries
for CPAP coverage under the new guidelines. Dr. Hoover said that prior polysomnograms would
be accepted for coverage under new guidelines. The DAC also asked how long a
polysomnogram could be used to verify medical necessity. Dr. Hoover indicated that providers
should use good judgment. He stated that a test 2-3 years old for a patient with no major changes
in medical condition (i.e., significant weight loss) would seem reasonable.
3
Kimberlie Rogers-Bowers asked if a supplier needs to ascertain continued use of the CPAP
between the 61
st
and 90
th
day of use for patients who were tested before July 1, 2002. Dr. Hoover
said the requirement only applies to patients tested on or after July 1, 2002.
CIGNA Provider Relations Update
Dolly Baughman asked for a show of hands of DAC members who have participated in
Webinars and who was unable to access Webinars. The majority of those present had attempted
to get on Webinars but did not succeed.
The DAC suggested that providers were unable to participate in Webinars due to the limitation
of 15 participants. They asked that CIGNA review the product currently being used by Region C
that allows for a greater number of participants.
Comments: Concerns were taken to management and we have increased our participants up to
30 per Webinar. We have added some new topics for June. They are EDI Basics HIPPA, and
Refractive Lenses. We will continue to have ABN and Upgrades and Completion of CMS 1500
Form.
Dolly thanked the DAC for feedback and she will take our comments back to Boise for review.
She indicated that CIGNA has scheduled the Webinars to repeat frequently, which should
provide greater access for providers.
Ms. Baughman also reported that the Fall Seminars are in the final stage of being scheduled.
Topics will include Avoiding Denials and Appeals Process. She has sent suggested locations to
Connie Lind-Fraher, DAC Education/Communication A-Team Leader.
Dr. Hoover asked for input from the DAC on how CIGNA can provide manual updates and
DMERC Dialogues as a downloadable file sent via e-mail or posted on the CIGNA website. The
HME A Team leader requested that the updates on the website be in a downloadable format
if/when posted on the website, i.e. PDF or HTML.
Common Working File Update
Wade Hendrickson asked CIGNA for an update on providers’ ability to access the Common
Working File (CWF). No update was available for this meeting.
Proof of Delivery Policy Paper Update
At the time of the meeting no update was available.
CIGNA Contacts – DAC Resource Between Quarterly Meetings
4
Dolly Baughman will be the CIGNA key contact for the DAC to address issues between quarterly
meetings. The DAC indicated that it would develop an internal procedure to assure that discretion is used
before contacting Ms. Baughman.
Review of Questions and Answers
Before beginning the discussion Laura McIlvaine, Chair reviewed the DAC meeting protocol
and reminded A-Team Leaders of their time limits.
Rehab A-Team
In response to CIGNA's answer to question #1: The Rehab A-team, requested clarification of the
definition of "custom made items." Val Taylor questioned if an item were custom fabricated by
manufactures to accommodate the specific needs of a given individual, verses, items simply
pulled off the shelf, would that item be considered custom? CIGNA replied that they agree with
our examples; however, they were uncertain how the claim would be dealt with.
Val Taylor also asked how "salvage value" is determined? Mary Rheinecker stated she would
follow up with a response
.
In response to question #3: Val Taylor asked Dr. Hoover for an estimated timeline on the
publication of a final draft on the wheelchair seating and positioning standards. He had no
response.
Previously Submitted Question – January 30, 2002
CIGNA confirmed that the CO-50 & CO-57 denials could be used as medical necessity denials.
However, the DAC will have to receive confirmation from CMS that these codes are infact
medical necessity denials. Therefore, the response is pending with Jim Underhill, who was not
present.
Infusion Therapy A-Team
Mike Hayden thanked CIGNA for their response and asked for Barbara Douglas’ contact
information. Mary Rheinecker provided the information.
(Here is the latest information sent to
Mike Hayden on June 3, 2002 from Barabara: In reviewing the "S" codes we have found there is
no DMERC benefit to proposing permanent HCPCS codes. I have forwarded your concerns to
our HIPAA core team as far as accepting the "S" codes in our system for a denial.)
Orthotics and Prosthetics A-Team
#17 – Dr. Hoover indicated that a national panel makes coding decisions. The DMERC can make
recommendations, but does not have the final decision. Dr. Hoover is aware of the DAC’s
concerns. He recommended that the DAC contact the American Orthotics and Prosthetics
Association (AOPA) to ask for their assistance on this issue.
5
#18 – Pending with Jim Underhill.
#19 – Medicare does not pay for preventative services. Dr. Hoover indicated that the DMERC
will consider reimbursement for contracture orthoses when used to treat contractures, but is
unable to approve for preventative measures. He indicated that he understands the DAC’s
concerns with this policy and recommended that the DAC write congressional leaders asking that
Medicare consider coverage of preventative services.
Dr. Hoover indicated that the DAC could contact him for suggestions on how to approach the
issue.
#21 – Medicare does not reimburse for repairs to prosthetics. Dr. Hoover indicated that the DAC
should get in contact with Barbara Douglas on this issue. Barbara should be able to assist the
DAC by putting them in contact with the pricing people.
In addition to the questions presented by the O&P A-Team Paul Webber asked Dr. Hoover the
status of the policy on the cleaning of ocular lenses. Dr. Hoover indicated that the policy change
is discretionary and he is anticipating publication in the fall.
Medical Supplies A-Team
A follow up question was brought up regarding the CWF and diabetic supplies. CIGNA had
responded to the Medical Supplies A-Team that CMS has been aware of the issue with CWF and
the spanning of dates issue. They stated that CMS is in the process of addressing it through a
program memorandum.
Sharon asked if CIGNA had tested all scenarios regarding this situation and if the testing was
complete. If so, what had they found?
CIGNA responded that the tests were complete and they would not deny any claims. CIGNA
indicated that they did not foresee any problems with the CWF and span dates.
Home Medical Equipment A-Team
For question #23, since 45% of the denials given as examples (13) were due to a CIGNA system
error, was there action that CIGNA was going take to address these on a global scale? CIGNA
responded that if the provider brought them to CIGNA’s attention they would be addressed, but
CIGNA was not going to take any additional action.
Dolly Baughman was to follow up with Kim Frushon on the answers to questions #24 and the
previously submitted question, as the examples were not fully researched at the time of the
meeting.
(This has been done and follow up completed by Kim Largent.)
REGION D DAC
MEETING with CIGNA - MINUTES
Wednesday, October 30, 2002
Georgia World Congress Center
Atlanta, GA
DAC Attendees:
Reid Bellis Deanne Birch Andy Boesl Kim Brunnett
Evan Call Dale Cleveland Mary A. Collins Colin Cooke
Cindy Coy Deborah Davis Colleen DeSantis Rick Graver
Carol Green Velma Goertzen Syd Gubin Chuck Gunther
Sarah Haines Jim Hanton Mike Hayden Wade Hendrickson
Zena Jacobi Kay Johnson Daniel Jurovich Janna Jurovich
Herb Langsam Connie Lind-Fraher Derek Lovesee Laura McIlvaine
Joe McKnight Therman Noville Troy Paz Rich Pozesky
Leslie Rigg Kimberlie Rogers-Bowers Sheila Showalter
Pat Spanel Maria Spencer Barb Stockert Val Taylor
Judy Thompson Angie Waddell Paul Webber Rosalie Webber
Tim Zipp
CIGNA Staff:
Robert Hoover, M.D. Doran Edwards, M.D. Dolly Baughman
Carla Cerchione Barbara Douglas Doug Frazier
Mary Rheineker Amanda Zumwalt
I. General Business
Introductions conducted. The minutes of the September 20, 2002 meeting were approved as
submitted.
II. Medical Director Update – Dr. Hoover
a. PCOM Advisory Group
Dr. Hoover summarized a new committee that was formed known as the Provider
Communication Advisory Group (PCOM). PCOM is an open to physicians, beneficiaries, and
DMEPOS providers that focuses on educational training issues with the DMERC. He announced
that Doug Frazier has been chosen as the Chair for PCOM.
Dr. Hoover reported that he has reviewed the focus of the PCOM with Wade Hendrickson and
solicited the Executive Committee’s opinion. He reviewed a letter written to the DAC on the
issue. He also noted that due to the specific focus of the PCOM he did not feel that it replaces the
DAC’s Education A-Team or did it set a precedence that could eliminate the DAC. It is to meet
CIGNA’s contractual obligation with CMS.
b. Upcoming bulletins
It was reported that the December DMERC Dialogue will have a new format and will include
new codes and new modifiers.
The CIGNA website will have a new format with improved user-friendly policies and an
improved search engine. The 2003 Fee schedule is available on the CIGNA web site. A live
crosswalk will also be available as a result of changes from HIPAA.
The DAC asked for clarification on whether manual and policy changes sent in electronic format
are considered the "official" policy. CIGNA indicated that no matter how the information is
distributed the last published is the "official" policy.
CIGNA encouraged provides to sign up for the ListServ. They reported that the list serve is being
improved to expand the amount of information distributed electronically. CIGNA is currently
testing to see if the information can be distributed more efficiently electronically. In the future
the list serve will include LMRP notices and manual updates.
CIGNA reported that as of October 2002 they would no longer be required to send hard copies of
the DMERC Dialogues or manual updates.
Dolly Baughman reported that the amount of Webinars would be expanding. Shortly after the
first of the year CIGNA hopes to have Net Courses available. Topics will be maintained on the
website so providers can repeat as desired.
c. Provider Satisfaction Survey
CIGNA will begin sending provider a 2-page satisfaction survey within the next 4-6 weeks. The
surveys will be sent randomly to providers with high denial rates. Will list resources that
providers can use to improve their billing as part of their education process. The survey will
focus on providers’ experiences with CIGNA Medicare.
III. Oxygen Policy Review Update: Dr. Hoover
The DAC inquired about the status of oxygen Local Medical Review Policy (LMRP). Dr.
Hoover indicated that it is still being reviewed, but not been completed due to workload issues.
He reported that he is currently working on three projects the oxygen LMRP, Wheelchair
Accessories K1008s, and the wheelchair seating policy.
The DMERC Medical Directors and the SADMERC, along with the Rehab Assistive Technology
Council of North America (RESNA), are working to establish new wheelchair accessory codes.
These will likely be out by summer 2003.
Dr. Hoover further indicated that the wheelchair seating policy is being handled as a top priority.
The policy has been rewritten and will be re-released for comment. However, at this time he does
not have time frame for the policies release.
Medical Director’s Conference Call Schedule
Dr. Hoover discussed how the four regional medical directors maintain consistency by meeting 3-
times per week via teleconference. The Directors promote consistency by sharing their Q&As
before they are returned to the DACs.
IV. PET (Provider Education & Training) Issues – Dolly Baughman
Dolly Baughman reported that the Medicare Safari seminars are going well. She indicated that the
DAC representation received good comments. One of the main topics CIGNA received questions
about was the KX modifier. The ANSI reason code denials were also discussed. Doug Frazier is
compiling all questions from the Medicare Safari, which some will then be posted in the DMERC
Dialogue or on the CIGNA website.
Ms. Baughman also discussed upcoming topics of the Webinars, the upcoming Net Courses,
which will include a CMS 1500 education course. She further emphasized the need for providers
to sign up for the List Serve.
Carla Cerchione provided a follow-up to a question that the DAC had at Medtrade Spring with
respect to provider’s ability to use of credit cards to register for Medicare Education Seminars.
She indicated that CIGNA is trying to resolve a technical issue that will allow providers to use
credit cards to register on-line. CIGNA hopes to resolve this issue by the next set of seminars.
V. HIPAA Migration
Amanda Zumwalt reported that CIGNA is currently testing software vendors for HIPAA
compliance. List serve participants frequently receive updates on ANSI approved vendors. It is
also available on CIGNA’s web site.
VI. Clarification of Information Sharing
There was discussion about electronic distribution of bulletins, policies, and manual updates.
CIGNA indicated that CMS feels that all providers should have access to the Internet. If not in
the facility they can go to the library. For the company that has paid a subscription to receive the
supplier manual CIGNA does not have to refund the money since it is now only available on the
web. Chuck Gunther suggested that through the provider enrollment process that one of the 21
supplier standards should be to have a PC.
CIGNA is exploring the idea of providing publications via a CD mailing rather than hard copy.
Getting approval from CMS. They will attempt to include all back issues of the DMERC
Dialogue, Supplier Manuals, etc. on a searchable CD. Will communicate this if available.
As a result of this discussion the DAC and CIGNA exchanged the following question and answer:
Question: Which is the official policy and guideline, printed or electronically
distributed? When is the actually effected date of items posted on the
website?
Answer: If posted on the web site take it as the official information. The effective
date is the date the item was posted on the Web Site or the date of e-mail.
Question: Is the exchange of information and clarification of policies as a result of
CIGNA’s communication with the DAC being shared with CIGNA
CSRs?
Answer: They are correcting the process to be consistent. CSRs have a 6-month
training period and then supervision on the telephone for a period of
time. Supervisors back up phones when CSRs receive training.
Dr. Hoover has started attending the CSR’s monthly training meetings. If
information is inconsistent get in writing or talk to the supervisor and get
their name. He uses information from the Q & A as part of his updates
during the training meetings.
The DAC was informed that CIGNA uses several sources for product
training and tends to use manufacturer’s representatives. Manufacturers
meet with Dr. Hoover before doing providing product training to the
CIGNA CSRs. They are prohibited from mention their specific product.
VII. A-Team Leaders review answers provided by CIGNA
Rehab A-Team ADMC Questions
Region D DMERC Advisory Committee (DAC)
Meeting with CIGNA Medicare
January 30, 2002
9:00am – 11:00am (PST)
Via Conference Call
MINUTES
PRESENT
Region D DAC Representatives:
Laura McIlvaine, Chair
Reid Bellis Deanne Birch Dale Cleveland Vince DeStigter
Rachel Eller Kim Frushon Velma Goertzen Syd Gubin
Chuck Gunther Diana Guth Maureen Hanna Mike Hayden
Wade Hendrickson David Hosman Mary Jackson Kay Johnson
Janna Jurovich Connie Lind-Fraher W.B. Mick Sharon Nichelson
Troy Paz Gloria Peterson Rich Pozesky Carlos Reyes
Kimberly Rogers-Bowers Martin Szmal Val Taylor
Paul Webber David Williams
Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS):
Jim Underhill
CIGNA (Boise):
Dolly Baughman Carrie Brown Carla Cerchione Doug Frazier
Melissa Hansen Lisa Fix Amanda Zumwalt
CIGNA (Nashville):
Robert Hoover, M.D., Medical Director
Barbara Douglas Kim Largent Anne Love Tricia Luna
Mary Rheinecker Shelly Tant
I. Role Call
Gloria Peterson conducted the role call. Laura McIlvaine briefly reminded participants of
the meeting structure.
II. Comments from Dr. Hoover
a. Local Medical Review Policy (LMRP) Meetings
Dr. Hoover described the process for deciding on the meeting location. He indicated
the following factors are considered during the decision process: